Friday, April 11, 2008

Summer Skin Cutter!


Ah. It's been a while. A long long while.

It is summer again. For most people, it's beach and pool and out-of-town time. For college students, ongoing classes. For high school, it's vacation.

For little boys - it's horror.

In the Philippines, more often than not, circumcision is a summer event. You'll find "Painless circumcision" or "Murang tuli" at every corner and clinics around your place.

Circumcision way back.
I browsed the net and found a compilation of why circumcision is performed.
  • a religious sacrifice
  • a rite of passage marking a little boy into a young adult
  • a sympathetic magic to ensure virility
  • as a means of suppressing sexual pleasure; remove excessive pleasure
  • an aid to hygiene where regular bathing is impractical
  • means of marking social status (lower or higher)
  • discourage masturbation or any sexual action
  • demonstration of one's ability to endure pain
  • increase men's attractiveness to women
  • symbolic castration (any action, surgical, chemical or otherwise, by which a male loses the functions of the testes or to a female loses the functions of the ovaries)
  • male counterpart to menstruation or breaking the hymen

Circumcision was an important issue for first century Jews and Christians. Philo Jaudeous, a first century author, defended that circumcision on several grounds, including health, cleanliness, fertility and as a symbol of "the excision of all superfluous and excessive pleasure." Another author mentioned that it was instituted for moral reasons - "for perfecting what is morally defective" (Maimonides).

In Europe, except the Jews, they don't really practice circumcision.

Ancient Greek artwork portrayed penises covered with foreskin (sometimes in exquisite detail), except in the portrayal or satyrs, barbarians, and lechers. To hide a circumcised penis, during the second century, men would attach copper weight (called the Judeum pondum) was hung from the remnants of the circumcised foreskin until, in time, they became sufficiently stretched to cover the glans. Celsus, a 2nd century Greek philosopher and opponent of Christianity, described two surgical techniquesin his medical treatise De Medicina to restore a foreskin. One technique is by cutting around the base of the glans to loosen the penile shaft. The skin was then stretch over the glans, allowing it to heal and giving it the appearance of an uncircumcised penis.

In 1870, Lewis Sayre, a prominent New York orthopedic surgeon and vice president of the newly-formed American Medical Association, examined a five-year-old boy who was unable to straighten his legs, and whose condition had so far defied treatment. He noted that the boys genitals were inflammed, and he hypothesized that the long term irritation of the boy's foreskin has paralyzed his knees via reflex neurosis. Sayre circumcised the boy, and within a few weeks, the boy recovered from the paralysis. After a few more incidents in which circumcision appeared effective in treating paralyzed joints, Sayre promoted circumcision as an orthopedic remedy.

Pros and Cons of circumcision.
  • It is easier to clean a circumcised penis. Although you can teach an uncircumcised boy to clean his own penis by retracting the foreskin, some kids end up having infection becauser of poor hygiene.
  • It may be a little odd, but I actually found a study performed to prove that the penis of an uncircumcised boy is more sensitive than a circumcised boy. It said that intact men enjoy four times more penile sensitivity. (more HERE)
"The most sensitive part of the penis is the preputial opening. The results confirmed that the frenulum and ridged band of the inner foreskin are highly erogenous structures that are routinely removed by circumcision, leaving the penis with one-fourth the fine-touch sensitivity it originally possessed." - Morris Sorrells, MD, lead researcher

Five sites on the penis-all regularly removed by circumcision-are more sensitive than the most sensitive site remaining on the circumcised penis.

"Oddly, the most sensitive site on the circumcised penis is the circumcision scar itself." - Robert Van Howe, Researcher pediatrician and statistician

Taken from the ACTUAL research:
  • Five locations on the uncircumcised penis that are routinely removed at circumcision had lower pressure thresholds than the ventral scar of the circumcised penis.
  • For womne, having a male partnet with a foreskin increased the duration and comfort of coitus, and increased the likelihood of achieving single and multiply orgasms.
  • The type of nerve endings in the penis vary with location. The glans penis primarily has free nerve ending that can sense deep pressure and pain. The transitional area from the external to the internal surface of the prepuce, or 'ridged band', has a pleated appearance that in continuous with the frenulum and has a high density of fine-touch neuroreceptors, such as Meissner's corpuscles. Based on this histology, the transitional region and the ventral surface of the prepuce would be expected to have lower thresholds for light touch.

  • Small risks are due to minor infection around the circumcised area, which can easily be solved by the family physician.
  • Public health benefits include protection from urinary tract infections, sexually transmitted HIV, HPV (responsible for cervical cancer and genital warts), syphilis and chancroid (STD characterized by painful sores on the genitalia), penile and prostate cancer, phimosis (male foreskin cannot be fully retracted from genitalia, thrush, and inflammatory dermatoses.
  • In females, circumcised partners provides protection from cervical cancer and chlamydia infection.

Female Circumcision.
Different terms:
  • female genital cutting
  • female genital mutilation
  • female circumcision
  • female genital mutilation/cutting
"all procedures involving partial or total removal of the external female genitalia or other injury to the female genital organs whether for cultural, religious or other non-therapeutic reasons." - WHO 2June2006
  • maintenance of cleanliness
  • maintenance of good health
  • preservation of virginity
  • enhancement of fertility
  • prevention of promiscuity
  • increase of matrimonial opportunities
  • pursuance of aesthetics
  • improvement of male sexual performance and pleasure
  • promotion of social and political cohesion
Type I
- removal or splitting of the clitoral hood (hoodectomy), with or without excision of the clitoris

Type II
- "excision of the clitoris with partial or total excision of the labia minora."
- also called khafd, meaning reduction in Arabic.

Type III: Infibulation with excision
- "excision of part or all of the external genitalia and stitching/narrowing of the vaginal opening"
- also known as "pharaonic circumcision."

Type IV: Other types
- "all other harmful procedures to the female genitalia for non-medical purposes, for example, pricking, piercing, incising, scraping and cauterization."

Ouch!!!!


Legal Issue!
In Oregon, a father (an attorney) is in the process of converting into Judaism. He wants his 12-year-old son Misha, who is in his custody, to be circumcised. The decision was opposed by Misha himself and his mother.

The court believes that Misha has the right to be consulted before the circumcision. It opened the doors to a possible change of custody, depending on the child's opinion.


References:
Doctors Opposing Circumcision
Noharmm Org
Wikipedia - Female Circumcision
Wikipedia - Circumcision
Nemours Foundation
Circinfo

3 comments:

Anonymous said...

What on earth is odd about the fact that cutting the most sensitive part off makes it less sensitive? What did you think it would do?

You're in the Philippines? SupĆ³t support groups are springing up. Men who still have all they were born with are tired of being treated like lepers - when in fact they are the lucky ones.

YeyKay! said...

I was talking about the STUDY that they made. It wasn't really "odd" in a weird sense, I just thought it was different.

I don't think there's something wrong with being intact. =) But yea, in the Philippines, if you're supot, they'll tease you and make fun of you.

Anonymous said...

Big con to circumcision - if it's done to a kid, then he has no choice.

Also, lots of women find it very difficult to orgasm with a circumcised man, but find sex FAR more pleasurable with an intact man.

There's literally not a single reason that a child should be circumcised. Leave it up to the individual when he's an adult, he can choose what to do with his own genitals.

Just a couple of factual points - the circumcised penis isn't easier to clean just following the circumcision. Infants who are intact need no special care, just wipe like a finger. Circumcised boys have an open wound to care for, and adhesions to prevent, making it MUCH more complicated to clean a circumcised boy.

Also, phimosis often gets brought up as this awful thing that needs preventing, but many men live happy, healthy lives without ever retracting their foreskin. The foreskin is not disease-prone, infection is rare. When circumcision is performed on babies, death has been known to occur as a result of shock or subsequent infection.

Really, the penis is healthy, so leave it alone! If an adult wants to cut pieces off, that's his choice - same as any other cosmetic surgery!